Learning to Lead: Why Doing More Is Holding You Back | Katie Anderson
welcome to Lead Smarter
the podcast where you'll hear powerful
no nonsense conversations about leadership
with today's top experts
and real world leaders like yourself
get the inside strategies
insights and secrets
they've Learned on the journey to lead smarter
let's dive in
today's guest is Katie Anderson
a leadership coach speaker
and author who helps leaders stop defaulting to doing
and start building real learning cultures
Katie is the author of learning to Lead
leading to learn inspired by her work with a 40 year
Toyota leader in Japan where she studied
what actually drives sustainable performance
people learning and systems
not heroic leaders swooping in with the answers
in this conversation
we talk about why leaders get stuck in the doer trap
how learning gets squeezed out in
results driven organizations
and what it really takes to create conditions
where teams think
adapt and grow let's get into it
hey Katie
thanks again for joining me
on the podcast
and for getting the chance to get to know you
I I really enjoyed our first call
and I am excited to talk to you
about your perspective on leadership
and some of the work that you're doing
with your own clients
and developing a community of leaders
um one of the things that we were talking about
when we first met you talked about leading to learn
and redefining the role of a leader
I wanted to ask you
you describe leadership as setting the direction
creating conditions and developing yourself
why is that shift so difficult for new leaders
yeah well
first let me give you some context of what that phrase
leading to learn means and where it came from
so I it comes from the title of my book
learning to Lead Leading to learn
which I wrote
out of a collaboration and partnership with a 40 year
Toyota leader that I got to know
when I was living in Japan
a decade ago and I was really interested
in why Toyota was such a successful company
both in terms of its products
but also it's really famous for its
its culture and a lot of organizations
around the world are trying to adopt
the Toyota production system
of the Toyota Way
which has often been known as like lean
or lean manufacturing
there are a lot of different words for it
but at the essence it's this learning culture
and so I was really intrigued to understand what
what's the secret sauce right
and so I was going I was asking Mr Yoshino
who's the subject of my book is how Yoshino
and he kept saying there's no secret
there's no secret and he said
actually the only secret to Toyota is its
attitude towards learning
and he said
we don't even notice and we take it for granted
and then everything else that I put together
from my experiences
and working with global organizations
being an internal change leader
and leader within healthcare organizations
and more came back to this simple comment that he made
that I synthesized that a leader's role is simple
it's to set the direction provide support
which is to create those conditions
for people to be successful
and three to develop yourself
and so you know
it all goes back to those three simple things
but they're actually they're
they're simple but not easy
and I believe
these are not just challenging for new leaders
to adopt but for leaders at all levels
because we are used to doing the doing
and to being the expert
and the person jumping in with the right answer
and saving the day what leadership requires us to do
whether or not you're the leader of like a project team
or stepping into a management leadership role
or even a senior executive
is that it's no longer about you
executing on everything and solving all the problems
and you know
being the technical expert
and whatever your field or domain is
it's about setting the clear direction for the
for the team like where do we need to go
what do we need to accomplish
and then help coach support
create the
the conditions and structures within the organization
for people your team members to be able to do that
and that requires us to develop ourselves
and so that shift though
from being an independent contributor
to being in a team leader or manager role
is a big shift and so
I think it can be really hard'cause
a lot of our identity can be wrapped up into well
if I'm not the one doing the doing well right
what you know
what like like how important am I
am I not valuable and so it's like
shifting our mindset to
what is the purpose of our role
and how do we actually create impact
and you create exponential impact by actually
creating a lot of people's capabilities
to do the doing
I I actually started myself as a
let's just call it like an ops manager
so what you're describing to me
I've always tried to figure out like
is there
is it more of a benefit to have been the person
who gets their hands dirty
does the things
and therefore they know the experience how to do it
is it more of a benefit to be that
have been that person and then lead
or it's
more of a liability'cause then you wanna jump in
and you wanna help you wanna do it yourself
versus somebody who's there to be a leader
and only support and is like
counting on the expertise
and the reason I asked this question is'cause I will
try as a leader
to surround myself
with people that know what they're doing
way better than me
and sometimes completely better than me
because I don't know anything
about developing a website
or coding in this way
so I can't lead you in that activity
but having been somebody who was
responsible for this thing
I might know what the experience is
what to look out for and
and maybe just if I think about it
rather than trying to take over for you
or do the thing for you
but now I know what it's like to have been you
and what I would have benefited from
if I had a leader that was giving me the spaces I need
in the areas that I work on like
do you see it as more of a benefit
to have been the person
and so that you know what that experience is
or is it would it be better
are you know
am I more likely to be effective as a leader
who's leading a team where
my whole purpose
and my whole experience is to be that leader
to give you that space
and not risk maybe trying to step in by accident
because I think I know better than you no
I I don't think it's a binary question
I think it's a really it's like a it's not an either or
they come with different benefits
and different challenges just as you laid out David
like when you have the technical knowledge
of the purpose of the group
like the product or service that you're building
from the technical right side
and you're
it is your habit comes from that place of doing
so that can be harder to
you have to even be more intentional about like
what's my role when am I the expert doer
when is my technical expertise needed
and when am I actually there to be the team leader
and creating the set the direction
provide the support right right now inversely
you know that it can be
so it can be really beneficial to have someone
whose expertise actually is just in leading teams
no matter what the the the discipline or the doing is
and that can be powerful where that maybe is
there is some downside of that is
it's harder to say the clear
like what's the direction we need to go
or to be that person who's jumping in
when there is help needed
so you just have to balance knowing where
what kind of support your team needs
and just told yourself you know
where do you pull that support in
and just being clear on that
but it can be much harder if you know the work
to not jump into the work
but I have to say
a lot of us have what I call the telling habit
even if we have no idea of what the work is
cause we have a ton of great ideas and so right like
like oh
I'm gonna jump in with all my ideas
have you tried this have you tried that
what about this what about that
even if we don't really even know the technical side
or the the real problem to be solved
so I say we all have to break the telling habit as well
um it just depends it can what the situation is
I completely agree
can I remember myself at almost like I
and I think maybe even other leaders
that you're describing
have this urge to contribute and as opposed to lead
and I was actually gonna what
what do you see leaders getting wrong
when they confuse being a strong contributor
like an individual contributor
versus being an effective leader
where do you see them getting that wrong most often
yeah you know
it it all in my my experience
both from my own self
when I fall into what I call this doer trap and right
the leaders that I work with
it doesn't come from like a malicious place
like I'm not intentionally trying to like
take it over and control it
it actually comes from a place of
wanting to help and like help move
either help move the project along
or you see someone
struggling and not have the right answer right away
so I wanna like
just jump in and like kinda give them the answer
but you know then
you're not really
teaching them how to get to the answer right
I think the where I see the the risk is
is when that's habitual and we're like jumping in
and we're think we're being helpful
but we're actually maybe in the in the mediacy
we're helping in that moment to get to the answer
but we're actually not creating sustainable conditions
for ongoing capability
problem solving collaboration and and what not
so it's that it's seeing the immediate thing
and that immediate reward versus the bigger picture
I find myself having a hard time finding that balance
I've just I was just having a conversation with my team
so I've got a new team member and she's being trained
and I am the team member that LED her
or has LED her in the past
like that's helping her come along is very much a doer
like effective
like knows that if she doesn't get the thing done
that it's possible that nobody
it'll slip through the cracks
so sometimes instead of taking the time
and maybe she doesn't even have the time
to make sure that the team member
who's getting trained knows how it
how it gets done sometimes she just executes
it I find myself sometimes going
swinging too hard in the other direction
like
asking questions that make this particular task
take way longer than it should have
but my goal is that that person knows
not just how to do it
but the context of why we're doing it
and then knows how to make decisions
how do you find the right balance on that
how do you know
when you should be giving them room to learn
versus when now's the time
I actually have to stop and get this thing done yeah
it's you know
it's it's about being more intentional
so like more proactive on it
rather than reactive
and have that be your default state
so yeah I mean
I totally totally can relate to that too
one of the
one of the questions I ask leaders to reflect on
it is not like
you don't have to give up your expertise
or your technical knowledge
but knowing and how to navigate this continuum
it's about when is it my problem to solve
or my technical expertise is needed in this
and when am I there to develop
the expertise of someone else
and right and so you can still be an expert
but be showing up in more of this leader as coach role
rather than
I'm showing up as the expert who's taking on
the execution of this of this task
so that's one thing so just like it's okay
you can still own your expertise and be more coach like
and then it's like yeah
we have to make we have to make trade offs right
like sometimes
we have a timeline
that allows us to have more space to
or ideally we build in some of this to our timeline
so we're not always so compressed
that we can ask more questions
and give someone some time to try something
or go figure something out and come back
and in do having more of the
sort of like that exploratory process in getting there
and other times like really it's like
this is due tomorrow and we don't have time
and then we have to say
this is not our time for learning
this is a time for executing
and we need to bring in our best expertise
to make this happen the trap is when we see
and everything is this like five alarm fire
that's like has to be fixed now
and then we never build that capability
so it's like
getting better as a leader of judging when
things are urgent critical
like a true crisis or emergency
or a deadline that has to be hit now
and then
how can we build in more space through the rest of our
our processes
so that we're not caught in that constant fire
just putting out fires and running around right
and we don't have any time to build capability
or ask questions cause we just gotta get it done right
we all been there like that ah
you know but there's a time and place for development
like
the kids running across the street and the cars coming
is not the time to say do you think you should stop
and you know that's right
no
I'm willing to bet I mean
I know you are working with Toyota
I'm willing to bet that that's a
probably a pretty heavy focus
like putting the systems in place
so that you can be as proactive as possible
so that addressing those kinds of moments
where everybody has to stop
and I've got to do this thing
that's an exception rather than the norm
I'm guessing that's correct
a big part of it a huge part
and especially in my time in Japan
and visiting Toyota a lot
and talking to Mr Yoshino
and others who have worked there
that is built into the culture
and they have a lot of time for what they call hansei
or it's the Japanese word for reflection
that learning process
it's built in to how they structure their work
there's time built in
it's part of your expectation of your daily work
for doing continuous improvement
or kaizen and that includes the experimentation
they've
they've created the structures in their organization
where then learning that is the secret
and they don't even notice
it's because it's already there
so we have to be much more intentional
about creating that because it maybe doesn't
exist as easily in our in our organization
and just to ask people to like
do more learning and problem solving isn't helpful
if we don't have the systems
structures and tools to support that as well yeah
and many of the clients I'm talking to
they're in much obviously Toyota's huge
so they're obviously
people I'm talking to are much smaller organizations
I am in a much smaller organization
yeah well
me too but I
I love the idea of like intentionally
proactively planning on learning
being part of what the process is like
it's part of it rather than it's always an exception
like the it's literally
learning is the exception for any process I'm in
typically to the process whereas like
you're talking about
literally taking it one step further back
and just creating room for learning
yes which is it sounds simple
but it's really genius
and I know that I'm not seeing it happen most
in most organizations I'm looking at well
we and and so I
I
this is across the board in most western organizations
I would say we
because we're in this habit of execution and doing
so we like plan do plan
do do
do do
do do
and really so there's the plan
do study
adjust cycle of learning right
it's like the right scientific experiment
Toyota puts a lot more emphasis on the study and adjust
phase like the plan
do study
adjust and like and we
and I I experience this for myself
I teach this and yet I still experience
we equate the action of doing with the impact
but really right
the balance impact comes from the collaborative
sort of synergistic action of doing and learning
doing and learning doing and learning
doing and learning and adjusting
and so if we miss out on that study part
we're just like throwing a ton
like ton of arrows and darts out
but we don't really know are we doing it right
we need to adjust like what's going on
and so
right everybody wants to correct
and have the accurate thing being done
but nobody wants to spend the time to do the correction
yeah yeah
right so that that that's a big
big barrier for us so slow down pause
take a even if it's like 2 minutes
do a little bit more reflection
it's like it doesn't have to be
I mean sometimes it needs to be bigger
but like if we can start building in these micro habits
it really does it does accelerate impact in the end
cause we're getting smarter
I think this might actually what you just described
kind of lead into the question
I wanted to ask you next which was
why does focusing on results first
often undermine the outcomes
that leaders are looking for yeah
you know so I
I talk a lot about people first
it's people and then process and then results
and if we're focusing
on the results or the business outcome only
you can be actually driving the wrong behavior
and we see this you know
in you know
things like oh
we have to have you know
on time delivery well
then people are maybe shortcutting quality
or other things because you
that's the metric that you've put on that's like
that's the result that matters
or we have these very convoluted processes
and not very efficient or whatever
if we focus just on the results
we might be able to get there
but if we focus on the people and the learning aspect
we're going to be able to build that sustainability
to get there better and faster
and in the long run and more effectively yes
we want results but if we're more process oriented
we're going to be more effective
ultimately over time in getting those results
that that makes sense and I wish
I don't know what would you recommend for a new
a small business like myself
or small businesses that are listening
who don't already have this built into their
their processes they're
they're in the western world way of thinking
where we should correct
I don't have time for correction
I don't have time to do it right
but I do have time to do it twice yeah
how how would you get somebody that's new
to try to adopt those processes to yeah
well first value it yes
defend adopt for sure
and I mean this is for I think any I mean
I'm I have a small business as well
I have to talk with my team members about how we
do this and you know
as well like
how do we build in that reflection and learning time
so you know the first and foremost is like
how much
what is the what is the impact of doing things twice
of all the waste like
think about like the time it takes to do the rework
or the amount of money you're spending on supplies
and parts for doing that
like quantify that cause that's real like that
and if you can right do it better the first time
then then you're actually saving a ton of time
money and and frustration for your people too
so it's even sort of like
learning to see and quantify the waste
in our organization you know
all those all those levels
and then the the thing that I
I recommend people do is start framing
so to start bringing in this sort of like
learning mindset
if we can frame what we're doing as a hypothesis
we're gonna do this and we expect X
like we're gonna do X and we expect y to happen
and then we can say in our short reflection
did what we expect actually happen as a result
if not why not
oh that's interesting
what do we need to do differently
so the more we can frame our action
is a hypothesis of what we think
the impact of the action will be
we can have a place for reflection
it doesn't have to be super complicated or anything
but like
you know I expect that if we do something different
we expect it's gonna improve by a certain amount
or I as a leader I you know
I expect wow if I can hold back in like
offering my solution and ask a few more questions
I expect that my team members
are going to come up with some better ideas
and let's see how that happen
like what what happens as a result
I'm curious right
so it helps yeah
that curiosity so really simple
and it can happen across complex problems
issues or simple smaller processes or behaviors
I I am thinking of like what you're describing to me
I think it to me makes sense
specifically like an operational sense
like I can see the benefit of that very easily
I can see how to communicate that
and it makes sense to the team members involved
and I know that well
some of the challenges we talked about is almost from
like a leadership perspective
where
we've got to try to build this into the processes and
and make time and space for that
so that the corrections can happen
and we can get the benefits over time
if you were talking to a leader small business
and that leader drives their business by results
maybe even by results that's been locked in by
let's just call it like the CFO
how would you articulate the value of building in
learning to a CFO
who's trying to identify it
by the numbers yeah
well again
I go back to this thing like
if we're continuing to have all this waste
and we don't have people who can see the waste
then what like
what's the quantifiable business metric on the time
the the the the product
like I guess the supplies all all those things
so quantify that and then go back to well
if we focus on having more learning
we expect that we're gonna see a reduction in waste
you know
if you know we frame it around that and then say OK
well did that actually happen
can we actually measure are we actually seeing
that our team members are having
are able to use their creativity to
focus on process improvement
and then what is the result of that
so you can definitely quantify it and that you know
no matter what organizations I've been working for
large healthcare organizations
we're always like well
what's the value of like focusing on people
and learning and process improvement
there's tangible and intangible value
but all of that can be translated to
ROI for the business really
and we just have to get better at that
value chain leadership behaviors leads to like
our people's capability
which leads to process improvement
which leads to tangible and intangible outcomes
which leads to true like results for the organization
and the more we can start looking at that
how we tell that story and measure it is really helpful
I wish I was in an like
that sounds like a fantastic way to kind of
tie everything together and I can see myself in
in my own business I can see my
my clients go into their business
and when they run into a problem
all hands on deck like heads down
focusing on the problem and being able to like
still maintain not just a process
but like a process that ties through to the entire
through the entire organization
the growth of the organization
and not letting yourself get derailed
I don't know if I'm asking a question
but it seems difficult to me to maintain that level of
like widespread focus and diligence to growth
and not letting people who
maybe are in small businesses
used to just firefighting
like you like we talked about
jumping in and solving the problem
while trying to hold on to the value of
let the process work the kinks out
yeah it
I mean that's just
it's like it's like
it's growing pains within your organization because
you know when you're super small
you know you are kind of the doer
the Jack of all trades right
and and if you want to set the organization
the business up for that next level of growth
it also means there has to be a shift in how
what how you're
you're performing you're acting
what the responsibility of your team members are
the systems and structures
you need for the organization
because if you if you're trying to have a larger
a larger company you're at that next level of growth
but you're still functioning at that other level
it's gonna crumble right
so it's not gonna happen
this happens at all different levels of
you know stages
if going from like a small
super small company to that next level
and then even to like a broader enterprise
like you have to solidify and shift
and that's gonna be hard cause we're
we have to let go of some things
sure redefine what that means and then
and grow capabilities as well at all levels of the
of the organization it sounds like
like I'm assuming
you've had these kinds of conversations
with leaders themselves
who are trying to evolve themselves
their own businesses
it sounds like these would be difficult conversations
to have and sometimes well
it can be difficult conversations to have
because sometimes they may recognize
you know I don't have a
the skill set
or the habits to take it to the next level yet
yep and that's probably where you come in
you're trying to give them
the advice and the roadmap to get there
because maybe they haven't done it themselves yet
yeah on that uh
before we wrapped up
I really wanted to ask you about if you could take uh
one sixty seconds and you could go into the past
and give yourself one piece of advice only
cause that's all the time you have no
and to prepare yourself to be more effective
in whatever direction in life you're trying to go
what would be the one piece of advice
you'd give yourself
yeah well
the one piece of advice really
would come down to what we've talked about here today
because what what I've been sharing is
is really from Learned experience
it's that your value doesn't depend on you
your expertise of doing your value is about
how do you create those conditions
for learning across an organization
so you gotta
get out of that habit of sharing all your great ideas
all the time
doesn't mean your great ideas aren't great ideas
but that is that the right place in time
and so break that telling habit
and really focus on your intention
like what's the impact you wanna have
and how are the behaviors or how you're showing up
does that really align with that
and those can be those aha moments
and when I had those realizations for myself
I started to make those shifts
so I realized how I'm showing up is no longer serving
the impact I wanna have
or need to have at this time in my life
that that is great advice to yourself
and and now that you're back into the present
I wanted to ask you
what is a book you're reading right now
that you think would be good for other people to
other than your own which I do want to point to
I want you to tell me other than your own book
what's a good book for somebody to read who's
I'm trying to develop themselves
yeah so I mean
there's so many books
it's not a book I'm currently reading right now
but it's a book I often go back to
so the Coaching Habit by Michael Bungay Stanier
he's been on my podcast as well
and it really talks about some really simple
coaching questions
that's like the book I wish I had written
cause I
I think it's very simple and practical about coaching
questions
you can ask that really help bring things forward
so um
it's a classic it's been out for a decade
but if you haven't read it
The Coaching Habit is very accessible
by Michael Bungay Stanier
and then go listen to him on my podcast
chain of learning
and for your own book uh
where would listeners
where should listeners go to pick up leading to learn
and learning to lead yeah
so it's learning to lead leading to learn
so you gotta learn to lead first
and then you can lead to learn
but it is a cycle so learning to lead
leading to learn is available on Amazon or in your
favorite you know online retailer it's also on audible
so if you prefer to listen
you can listen to me read the book
and get some insights from an awesome little clip
it's from Mr Yoshino as well
and it's available in ebook
hardback soft pack
um paperback
whatever softback paper
all the ways all all all the ways and and audio too
so yep the easiest place is probably um on Amazon
but there
it's available across online retailers as well
and you can go check out my website in the book
like learning to lead
leading to learn.com and then KBJ
Anderson dot com as well
perfect well
thank you so much Katie it's been great talking to you
um thank you for the advice
and for the resources that we can go check out
I'm gonna point listeners to go check that out
after this episode
thank you again and looking forward to chatting again
yeah thanks for having me David
hey
thanks for listening to this episode of Lead Smarter
and thank you to the partners and sponsors
who believe in our mission
to evolve ourselves to elevate others
speaking of elevating others
if you like this episode please be sure to like follow
subscribe and share it would mean a lot to me
and the team that works so hard behind the scenes
so we can all learn together
and of course thank you to the expert guests
who kindly join us as generous guides
on our journey to lead smarter
